Biometric card pilot scorecard

A vendor-neutral scorecard for measuring enrollment, authentication, compatibility, recovery, support and cost before a wider rollout.

My Biometric Cards editorial desk·8 min read·Published September 30, 2026

Area	Measure during the pilot	Pass criterion to define before testing
Enrollment	Completion rate, median time, failed captures, assisted enrollments	Target rate and maximum support time
Daily use	First-attempt success, retries, authentication time, user satisfaction	Minimum success rate by user group and environment
Compatibility	Every reader, controller, OS, browser, app and identity-provider path	No unapproved gaps in the production matrix
Security	Lost card, revocation, lockout, fallback and recovery exercises	Recovery assurance equal to the primary method
Operations	Help-desk contacts, replacements, offboarding and inventory accuracy	Named owners and acceptable service levels
Economics	Card, reader, integration, support and replacement cost	Agreed total-cost threshold and comparison baseline

No email or form required.

How to use this scorecard

Print this page or save it as a PDF. Define thresholds before the pilot begins, record both successful and failed journeys, and segment results by user group, location, reader and platform. Do not replace measured results with a vendor demonstration.

1. Scope and baseline

Record the business problem, current authentication method, target users, exact card model and firmware, credential technologies, readers, controllers, operating systems, identity provider, applications and expected volume. Capture the current failure, support and recovery baseline.

2. Enrollment

Measure invitation completion, successful first enrollment, time to enroll, failed fingerprint capture, accessibility exceptions and administrator effort. Record where the biometric template is created and stored and who can initiate reset or re-enrollment.

3. Authentication and access

Measure first-attempt success, retries and time for every door, workstation, browser and application path. Include wet, dry or worn fingerprints, protective equipment, different card orientations, older readers and peak-use conditions.

4. Loss, recovery and offboarding

Run timed exercises for loss reporting, credential revocation, temporary access, identity proofing, replacement, re-enrollment and employee departure. Confirm old credentials cannot be used and that recovery does not fall back to a weaker phishable method.

5. Operations and total cost

Track help-desk contacts, inventory accuracy, failed cards, replacements, reader changes, training, management tooling and integration work. Compare total pilot and forecast operating cost with the current method and with at least one alternative.

Decision record

End with one of three outcomes: proceed to a bounded expansion, remediate and repeat defined tests, or stop. Document exceptions, evidence, owner, date and the exact product configuration approved. A successful pilot is not permission to substitute a different card or firmware.

COMMON QUESTIONS

Frequently asked questions

When should pilot thresholds be defined?

Before testing begins. Predefined thresholds reduce the risk of interpreting weak results as success after the fact.

Should a pilot test only normal users?

No. Include difficult fingerprints, accessibility needs, older readers, different platforms, loss, recovery, offboarding and help-desk operations.

Does a successful pilot approve every card in a product family?

No. Approval should identify the exact model, configuration and firmware that produced the measured results.